Last Updated on November 19, 2026 by Adrienne Mathis

From when to consider informal resolution to what makes an agreement effective, our experts answer four common questions raised by Title IX professionals.

Informal resolution can offer a meaningful alternative to the formal Title IX grievance process, depending on the circumstances and the outcomes the parties hope to achieve. Following our Informal Resolution Role Roundtable, we’ve gathered questions submitted by participants and asked our experts to share their perspectives.

For Title IX professionals, helping parties understand their options is an important part of their role. That means clearly explaining what each process involves and ensuring parties can make informed, voluntary decisions without feeling pressured toward a particular choice.

1. When can Title IX informal resolution be considered?

Under the 2020 Title IX regulations, informal resolution can be considered at any time after a formal complaint has been filed and before a determination regarding responsibility has been issued, provided the matter is eligible and the institution’s policy permits it.

This means informal resolution isn’t only an option at the beginning of a case. Parties may express interest at any point during the investigation, including during or after an investigative interview, after reviewing a preliminary investigative report, or as they prepare for a hearing. At any of these points, informal resolution may offer a different path forward if both parties voluntarily agree to participate.

It’s also not uncommon for a complainant to express interest in informal resolution but hesitate to file a formal complaint, which is required to initiate the Title IX informal resolution process. In these circumstances, it’s important to understand the reasons for that hesitation. Is the complainant uncertain about what filing a complaint means or what happens if informal resolution is unsuccessful? Do they have concerns about participating in a formal investigation or hearing? Do they understand the distinction between informal resolution and supportive measures? Understanding these concerns can help the Title IX Coordinator clarify what filing a formal complaint entails, what informal resolution could involve, and what options may remain available if the parties do not reach an agreement.

Each situation requires consideration of the allegations, the parties’ circumstances, and the institution’s policies and obligations. When the path forward isn’t clear, another experienced Title IX professional, such as an outside consultant or Coordinator mentor, can help work through the case-specific questions.

A Note on Documentation

Should the Notice of Allegations and informal resolution paperwork be combined?

We recommend keeping these documents separate. The Notice of Allegations establishes the allegations and explains many of the rights afforded the parties throughout the grievance process, while the informal resolution documentation addresses a distinct, voluntary process. Keeping them separate supports informed consent, helps ensure the parties understand the allegations before deciding whether to engage in informal resolution, and avoids potential confusion if either party withdraws from informal resolution and the formal grievance process resumes.

2. How can Title IX professionals explain informal resolution in a way that sets clear expectations and helps parties make informed decisions?

While the Notice of Allegations will state that informal resolution may be an option, a thoughtful conversation helps parties understand what participation in informal resolution might involve. It permits them the opportunity to ask questions and consider which process may be right for them.

Explain what informal resolution can look like

A Title IX Coordinator can share with the parties what the informal resolution process actually entails, or can entail, at their institution. For example, shuttle negotiation is one approach in which a neutral facilitator communicates separately with each party to explore potential resolution terms. This can take different forms, including separate in-person meetings, individual Zoom meetings, or email exchanges. The parties do not need to interact directly.

Restorative justice is another approach that focuses on understanding the impact of reported conduct and exploring ways to address harm. Depending on the circumstances, restorative processes may involve a broader group of affected individuals. For example, when an incident affects a larger community, a restorative process might include members of a campus group or affected staff, rather than focusing solely on the two parties directly involved.

The approaches available depend on the institution’s policies and the circumstances of the matter. An experienced informal resolution facilitator can meet individually with the parties, explain how the process would work, and understand their concerns and preferences before proceeding.

For a broader overview of the process and the Title IX Coordinator’s role, see our guide, What You Need to Know About Title IX Informal Resolution.

Help parties understand their options

Title IX professionals should also explain the differences between informal resolution and the formal grievance process, recognizing that parties may benefit from different aspects of each.

  • Opportunity to share their experiences. A formal investigation allows parties to provide detailed accounts, present evidence, and have witnesses interviewed. Some parties may value having their experiences fully documented and examined through a formal process. Others may prefer that informal resolution does not require them to participate in an investigative interview or hearing. 
  • Influence over outcomes and potential consequences. Informal resolution allows parties to help develop mutually agreeable terms that address their concerns. In the formal process, the institution determines responsibility and any resulting sanctions, and might not take into account, or even be aware of, what sanctions the complainant seeks. For example, a complainant might solely wish that a respondent withdraw from a shared campus program, rather than receive a temporary suspension. Conversely, the formal process may result in more significant or lasting consequences, such as expulsion, which a respondent would be unlikely to  accept through informal resolution.
  • Time and participation. Informal resolution is likely to take less time than a full investigation, and some institutions establish specific timelines for completing the process. It may also involve fewer university personnel and witnesses. Some parties may appreciate a shorter process with fewer people involved, while others may value the additional participation and fact-finding associated with a formal investigation and hearing.

Set clear expectations

Despite its name, informal resolution does not mean that the outcome is less significant or that agreed-upon terms are optional. Once a final agreement is reached, its terms are binding under the institution’s process and should be enforceable.

At the same time, either party can withdraw from the informal resolution process at any point prior to agreeing to a resolution and return to the formal grievance process. Parties should understand this right, along with the anticipated timeline, the facilitator’s role, and what participation will involve.

Title IX Coordinators should feel comfortable revisiting with the parties the option of informal resolution as a case progresses, though with caution. Just as they may remind parties that supportive measures remain available, they can remind them that informal resolution continues to be an option. The important distinction is how the conversation is framed: the goal is to ensure parties understand their choices, not to encourage them toward a particular process.

3. Can a Title IX investigator also facilitate informal resolution in the same case?

We recommend assigning different individuals to these roles within the same case.

One significant concern is confidentiality. During informal resolution, parties may share information, acknowledge certain circumstances, or discuss possible outcomes that they would not want factored into a formal investigation.

If a party withdraws from informal resolution and the formal grievance process resumes, an investigator who previously served as the facilitator may have difficulty separating information learned during those discussions from evidence gathered through the investigative process.

Even if the investigator remains impartial, the dual role can create an appearance of bias. For example, a respondent may be asked, and be willing, to express remorse for their actions during the informal process, but maintain their lack of responsibility for a policy violation if and when the formal process resumes. The arrangement may also affect the informal resolution process itself. Parties could be less willing to speak openly with a facilitator if they know that person might later investigate the same allegations.

For institutions with limited Title IX staffing, professionals can be trained to serve in both capacities across different matters. The concern is not whether someone can possess both skill sets, but whether the roles should overlap in the same case.

“Effective informal resolution requires a unique mix of listening skills, judgment, and creativity to develop solutions that address the parties’ needs in each case.”

— Adrienne Mathis

4. What makes an informal resolution agreement meaningful and effective?

The starting point for developing an effective informal resolution agreement should be understanding what the parties hope to achieve. Rather than beginning with a standard set of provisions, a skilled facilitator listens to the parties and explores solutions that address their concerns within the institution’s policies.

For example, parties may want to avoid continued contact in shared campus spaces or activities. An agreement might include one party withdrawing from an athletic team or student organization, changing housing arrangements, or establishing provisions for participation in particular courses or academic programs.

Other agreements may incorporate an educational component. Rather than simply requiring a written essay, for example, a facilitator might explore whether an oral presentation on a topic such as consent would better address what the parties hope to accomplish. As with all terms, such an arrangement would need to be mutually agreed upon and feasible for any campus personnel involved.

The agreement must also be workable and enforceable.

Consider an agreement intended to prevent contact between two students. What happens if they both arrive at the same campus event? If the agreement involves adjustments to course schedules, can the institution accommodate those changes without creating academic conflicts? If one party agrees to withdraw from a program, how will the institution implement and monitor that arrangement?

Answering these questions may require the facilitator to work with the Title IX Coordinator and other campus departments. Depending on the proposed terms, the Coordinator may need to consult with the registrar, residential life, campus safety, athletics, or study abroad staff to confirm that the agreement can be implemented. The details for how these future possible circumstances must be navigated should be incorporated into the agreement.

It is also important to establish clear expectations for compliance, including what happens if a party fails to follow the agreement. Terms should be specific enough that the institution can determine whether they have been met and address violations when necessary. Many institutions treat alleged violations for the agreement as a possible Code of Conduct violation.

 

Please Note: The information provided in this article is for educational purposes only and is not intended to be legal advice. We recommend seeking independent legal advice concerning the issues presented in evaluating a particular incident.

More questions about Title IX Informal Resolution?

Whether your institution is navigating a complex case or needs an experienced informal resolution facilitator, we can help. Our professionals provide case-specific guidance and neutral facilitation to help institutions evaluate their options and navigate the informal resolution process.

Learn About Our Informal Resolution Facilitators →

Authors

  • Adrienne Mathis

    Adrienne Mathis is the Executive Director at TIXS, where she helps university Title IX Coordinators navigate sexual harassment statutes and implement trauma-informed best practices. A former Fulbright Research Fellow, Adrienne previously drafted landmark sexual misconduct policies for Ecuador’s top university. Today, she specializes in policy audits, training program design, and safety strategies for U.S. students abroad. Her higher education insights have been featured in The Chronicle of Higher Education.

  • Susanna Murphy, JD

    Susanna Murphy is an independent Title IX advisor, investigator, and expert witness with over 20 years of criminal justice legal experience as a trial attorney and investigator. On behalf of Title IX Solutions, she provides comprehensive compliance training and misconduct prevention programming nationwide. Known for her objectivity, discretion, and trauma-informed approach, Susanna excels at navigating highly sensitive allegations while ensuring all parties and witnesses feel respected and comfortable.